A year ago, my granddaughters arrived with a very big surprise.
They were born at home, and no one knew there were two of them.
As a pediatrician, I had thoughts about all of this.
A lot of them.
Like so many of us in medicine, I had spent decades being trained to notice risk, prevent worst-case scenarios, and offer advice. That training is deeply ingrained. It is part of how we care. It is part of how we have learned to be useful in the world.
But in this instance, my role was not to be a physician with opinions.
I was a mom to my son, a mother-in-law to my daughter-in-law, and “Lita” to two little girls.
Those roles asked something different of me.
They asked me to be present. To stay curious. To make room for my own feelings without making them everyone else’s problem. To remember that the people I love get to make their own choices.
A year later, I feel proud of the way I navigated it—not perfectly, but with grace, presence, and especially love.
The question that changed how I showed up
Three days after the twins were born, I gave my TEDx talk, “What Would Love Do?”
That question became a practical guide for me in the year that followed.
No amount of judgment would change what had already happened. No amount of expertise would let me control another family’s decisions. And, as psychologist Shauna Shapiro says, “the most important thing is the most important thing.”
What mattered most to me was having a relationship with my son, my daughter-in-law, and my granddaughters.
Not being right.
Not being seen as the expert.
Not making sure everyone knew what I would have chosen.
A relationship.
Love and expertise are not the same thing
This was not an invitation to pretend I am not a pediatrician. I am. My knowledge and experience are real and part of me.
But expertise and love are not the same thing.
The people we love get to make their own choices. And we get to choose how we show up in response.
With connection or control.
With judgment or curiosity.
With fear or love.
For those of us trained in medicine, this can be harder than it sounds. We are conditioned to think ahead, notice what could go wrong, and feel responsible for preventing harm. Sometimes that is exactly what is needed.
And sometimes the most important work is to pause long enough to ask: What is mine to carry here? What is not? What would love do?
Presence is not passive
Choosing a nonjudgmental presence does not mean we do not care. It does not mean we have no opinions or concerns. It does not mean we stop being who we are.
It means we become intentional about how we use our energy.
It means we remember that control is not the same as connection.
It means we make room for another person’s autonomy, even when their choices feel unfamiliar or uncomfortable.
And it means we offer ourselves compassion, too. We are allowed to have feelings. We are allowed to be surprised, worried, disappointed, or confused. The practice is not to eliminate those feelings. The practice is to choose what we do with them.
A year later
On these two sweet girls’ first birthday, I feel grateful.
Grateful for their arrival. Grateful for their healthy existence. Grateful for all that this year has taught me.
I am reminded again that growth is humbling. Curiosity and love are superpowers. And almost always, the most loving thing we can offer the people we love is not more advice or more expertise.
It is our nonjudgmental presence.
If you are navigating a situation where your knowledge, hopes, or fears are bumping up against someone else’s choices, you might pause and ask yourself:
What matters most here?
And what would love do?
If you would like support bringing more curiosity, love, and presence to your own complicated life, I offer one-to-one coaching, topic-based small groups, and retreats.
If this resonates, you may also enjoy listening to the Healing Medicine episode, When Family Health Decisions Conflict with Your Medical Training, where Dr. Ni-Cheng Liang and I explore the tender space between medical expertise, autonomy, and love in our families.
You can also read my related KevinMD article, Pediatrician vs. grandmother: Choosing love over medical advice.
The episode directly addresses family health decisions that conflict with medical training, and the KevinMD article is a companion personal reflection. Podcast episode, KevinMD article